It's hard for me to even think of this as a radio piece because I'm so in awe of the man and his story. I loved this and I hope it's aired where I live and everywhere.
This is the first of the series I listened to, and the subject is, in my mind, the most intriguing of the four segments. Perhaps Rodney Crowell's delivery is a little forced in places, but his intimacy with the subject is not.
Zeroing in on the Vietnam War was a good choice, and if anything, I could have stood a little more background on just how Cash's "stance" against the war was manifest. I guess we hear it in the "Man in Black" song and the other song about truth (which I'd never heard before--Cash's catalogue is bottomless!) but I wonder to what extent his views on the war were public, except as interpretable in the songs. Cash remains a hero to the type of "Country Music Fan" to the easily stereo-typed right wing Christian conservative country fan. We heard a lot from the younger generation and Cash's close friends (his children and sons in law, his bass player) but not so much from the generation of Cash fans who would have supported the war at the time.
Obviously, I was extremely engaged intellectually and emotionally in the segment. I hope to hear this on the radio soon. The inclusion of Rosanne's description of Cash's reaction to the war is some of the most powerful tape I've heard. The decision to include it in the piece is courageous and I appreciate it.
This is wonderful piece and I can't wait to hear the rest of the series. Johnny Cash is an American who defies and defied so much of our culture. That paradox is clear in this piece and presented in thoughtful way...so much in fact, that I feel compelled to learn more about him.
That's good radio.
Some technical notes though. First, music beds under the extended interview segments would be helpful, especially for music stations. Music listeners don't want talk but as long as there is guitar strumming underneath the words, they'll be cool. Second, celebrity hosts are great if they are great hosts. This host is a bit flat, shame to say, but not so much to prevent any station from complaining or airing the program.
Be forewarned, this piece describes Johnny's political and social points of view with very little fussing. You wouldn't want a sanded down version of the Man in Black and this piece delivers.
Comments for Johnny Cash: The Man in Black
This piece belongs to the series "Johnny Cash: Legend"
Produced by Paul Chuffo, Joyride Media
Other pieces by Joyride Media
Rating Summary
2 comments
Jesse Dukes
Posted on October 15, 2005 at 05:01 AM | Permalink
Review of Johnny Cash: The Man in Black
It's hard for me to even think of this as a radio piece because I'm so in awe of the man and his story. I loved this and I hope it's aired where I live and everywhere.
This is the first of the series I listened to, and the subject is, in my mind, the most intriguing of the four segments. Perhaps Rodney Crowell's delivery is a little forced in places, but his intimacy with the subject is not.
Zeroing in on the Vietnam War was a good choice, and if anything, I could have stood a little more background on just how Cash's "stance" against the war was manifest. I guess we hear it in the "Man in Black" song and the other song about truth (which I'd never heard before--Cash's catalogue is bottomless!) but I wonder to what extent his views on the war were public, except as interpretable in the songs. Cash remains a hero to the type of "Country Music Fan" to the easily stereo-typed right wing Christian conservative country fan. We heard a lot from the younger generation and Cash's close friends (his children and sons in law, his bass player) but not so much from the generation of Cash fans who would have supported the war at the time.
Obviously, I was extremely engaged intellectually and emotionally in the segment. I hope to hear this on the radio soon. The inclusion of Rosanne's description of Cash's reaction to the war is some of the most powerful tape I've heard. The decision to include it in the piece is courageous and I appreciate it.
Steve Yasko
Posted on August 20, 2005 at 09:08 AM | Permalink
Review of Johnny Cash: The Man in Black
The Man in Black is Still In.
This is wonderful piece and I can't wait to hear the rest of the series. Johnny Cash is an American who defies and defied so much of our culture. That paradox is clear in this piece and presented in thoughtful way...so much in fact, that I feel compelled to learn more about him.
That's good radio.
Some technical notes though. First, music beds under the extended interview segments would be helpful, especially for music stations. Music listeners don't want talk but as long as there is guitar strumming underneath the words, they'll be cool. Second, celebrity hosts are great if they are great hosts. This host is a bit flat, shame to say, but not so much to prevent any station from complaining or airing the program.
Be forewarned, this piece describes Johnny's political and social points of view with very little fussing. You wouldn't want a sanded down version of the Man in Black and this piece delivers.