Comments by brian moffatt

Comment for "The Emergence of Bob Dylan" (deleted)

User image

Review of The Emergence of Bob Dylan (deleted)

Well, I'm pretty much Dylan-ed out. Hung over from yesterday's four hour feast of radio listening here at prx and then the Scorcese flick last night pn PBS. I feel I have a vague idea of what 'the scene' was like. The only thing missing from the Ingles doc here are the interviews with the man himself. Dylan, not Ingles. Pretty much everything else is covered off with as much artistry and craftmanship as any Dylan tune, like a walk through The Museum - used very effectively in the first hour as both structure and source. And after listening to this piece, I feel much closer to the power of the music of the man - his voice and his lyrics. Watching the tele-film, I felt a little closer to his voice and persona, his social significance. As it was the lyrics and the songwriting - the poetry - that first drew me to Dylan - well after his finger pointing years, long after - this Ingles doc works wonders in revealing some - to me - unheard wonders. A deeper, broader Dylan.

Comment for "This American Life: After the Flood" (deleted)

User image

Review of This American Life: After the Flood (deleted)

This is my first listen to This American Life. Darn furner that I am. Of course I have heard of the programme. If there is a better hour in the series I'd be shocked. The dynamic of the (nearly) unemediated voice - in this particular case, victims of god and country - is just so attractive. Sad, funny, shocking, uplifting - yet never depressing. A three run home run.

Comment for "Bob Dylan: No Direction Home"

User image

Review of Bob Dylan: No Direction Home

For the general listener - like myself - this is a fine intro to the early years in Bob Dylan's musical life. There is enough balance, between the familar and the never-before-heard, to keep the inattentive and unitiated hooked for two hours while cleaning up around the house. I'm not sure what sort of shelf life this sort of narrow (in a good way) and understated piece will have - I supect little. I am left wanting more, that's for sure. Not a bad thing. As a result of listening, I may tune into the Scorcese doc tonight. Mission accomplished. Sort of.

Comment for "Squirrel Duels. . . Offramp"

User image

Review of Squirrel Duels. . . Offramp

Bizarre. Very funny. Throw this in between some somber and/or sober pieces for a real mindbreak. Nice to see somebody doing some improv that doesn't rely on whack over the top zaniness and stooge trickery. Undergound cerebral duelling with an overbite. Gotta love that.

Comment for "Little Gray Book Lecture: How to Communicate Without the Use of Wires"

User image

Review of Little Gray Book Lecture: How to Communicate Without the Use

I disagree with the reviewer above who dislikes the embroidery around the two main stories. The whole package rocks. Well...gently. I listened to this on a Friday evening after a long and arduous week of Much Noise. This show is da balm.

Repurposed Art Bell. A Haunted motel. Contacting aliens. Fun with walkie talkies. All a bit whack, as so little of radio - anywhere - is, genuinely, these days.

I'm glad to see these folks are podcasting and dividing the shows into 'minividual' segments which I assume are available for pds.

This is the sort of thing meant for restless nights or long drives. Nice use of white space. Excellent tone.

Special kudos to J. Coulton: personally I can't stand singer/guitarist/humorists (it a long story, same with mimes and sockpuppeteers) but he won me over with his song about the E-poppin', Red Bull quaffin', rave attendin', news anchor.

The theme of The Romance of Over the Air Radio works well coming through the wires too.

Comment for "We see it all: life through the eyes of a photo developer"

User image

Review of We see it all: life through the eyes of a photo developer

The subject of this piece - a one hour film lab developer and part time wedding photographer - has obviously thought long and hard about 'snapshots' and offers a whole whack of world weary opinions and near misanthropic ideas on the matter in this piece.

Very well put together. Voyeurism, photography as faux art, contextualism, albums as self-delusion. It's all here. Loaded for bear. I really enjoyed listening to this.

Comment for "B-Side: Caught on Tape"

User image

Review of B-Side: Caught on Tape

An extremely well produced half hour of light radio. And I don't mean light and fluffy. I mean light as in the absence of weight. I'd want to hear this on a Saturday afternoon, in the house, with the windows open, and a breeze blowing in.

It blows me away that this is essenitally 'community radio'. It's as well put together as anything I've heard on a national level - on the NPR wafting across the lake or on CBC here in Canada. The writing, recording, editing, and voicing are all deft, and self-assured.

The strength of this piece lies in what might be perceived as its weakness, at least judging by the tone and substance of much public radio. This piece is very much about the people making the piece. But somehow it works. It is extremely difficult to pull off this sort of thing without coming off as self-indulgent or self-important. But the crew manages to do it.

It's fun, personal, charming. These are the sort of folks you'd like to have hanging out around your house telling stories over a weekend mid-day tea break.

Comment for "Pop Vultures #10: The Neptunes & Musical Epiphanies" (deleted)

User image

Review of Pop Vultures #10: The Neptunes & Musical Epiphanies (deleted)

After a lumbering false start mired in a collegial faux musicology, where our host Kate Sullivan seems to be talking to someone other than me - the listener - and at the same time speaking to, or with, no one in particular, this programme really begins to cook.

This is the second in the series of Pop Vultures that I have heard, and the criticism levelled upon first exposure (Kanye West) holds here: we have a structural flaw.

Chop the first ten minutes and you're into this wonderful heart felt stuff from individuals, telling tales about love lost and found and the profound and deep ways music - from the sublime to the awful - can effect lives and change perceptions, frickin' well transform people.

Kate's obvious talent - apart from any knowledge of music - lies in her ability to draw people into a conversation - to listen and to temper. At least going by this episode.

Not that every show in the series needs to be that thing, but each show does need to be one thing. Or do the blending thing - a radio technique I personally love - but blend to the end.

All in all this stuff, or this programme in particular - is well worth a listen. Good stuff.


Comment for "Independent Minds: Peter Sellers"

User image

Review of Independent Minds: Peter Sellers

A slick, comprehensive look at the professional life of the comic genius Peter Sellers. This is a very well paced doc examining the arc of Seller's career, with due emphasis spent on his quality work. Perhaps I'm appreciating this piece because it aligns so closely with my opinion of Sellers and his work. I've always assumed I own or have seen or was, at least, aware of everything Peter Sellers ever did - from the brilliant to the awful. But no. I was unaware of a 1973 English film entitled The Optimists. I'm always shocked when I read shots aimed at the man and his performances - one I read in which the reviewer - well known - claimed that Sellers' three turn performance in Dr. Strangelove ruined the film. Huh? Sellers was mad, no doubt. And this piece does not shy away from that reality. The nuance in his vocal impressions was otherworldy. He was most definitely touched by something. His difficulties in getting on with the practical matters in life - or on a movie set, for that matter - are herein dealt with appropriately. If you only know Sellers from his bumbling as Clousseau, then this should be a real ear opener. Mike Myers, one of the interviewees would have us remember Sellers as a genius, singularly, ignoring or 'walking away' from his flaws. But it's the cracks that make the crack genius.

Comment for "Pop Vultures #21: Kanye West & Heroes of Seduction" (deleted)

User image

Review of Pop Vultures #21: Kanye West & Heroes of Seduction (deleted)

I have to admit I'm slightly confused by this piece.

And I've had to reread the review guidelines before I begin here. This is the sort of piece I'd like to hear - but not in the format presented. It's prepackaged production attempting to come off as impromptu, off the cuff observation and commentary. A mix of music and talk. We could stand to hear a little more music. Or talk. One or the other. Or go 'live'.

As an elder statesman I'm keen to hear what the kids are listening to. And my thirteen year old introduced me to Kanye West a year ago. Kanye is his hero. He gets Kanye. He knows Kanye's story. And if he were writing this review he'd slam the show. For the apparent lack of that little thing known as 'attention to detail.'

Not that the details - the facts - are wrong. His question - mine as well - why the coy play? Why make it sound like you don't know, when you do. And if you don't know, there's this thing called the internet...

And if not more music, them more talk that is less disingenuous.

There is some really good stuff in here - about perceptions on sexuality and seduction, the interweaving of the music of Kanye West, Prince, and Rick James - and if I was a PD - which I'm not - I'd be on the blower wondering if this material couldn't be reworked - the problem is not editorial, it's structural. The centre does not hold.

All in all, the pop aspect of the programme offsets the internal flaws and warrants some attention. Public radio needs more of this.

Comment for "Recuperated: Occupied Factories in Argentina"

User image

Review of Recuperated: Occupied Factories in Argentina

This piece turns workers rights issues upside down and sideways. Textile workers in Argentina - very articulate ones at that - take over a factory that is being abandoned. For these workers the issue is not working conditions or safety, but the base condition, survival.

The struggle is practical. Ethical as well. About legitmacy (working and feeding your family) and why - despite the inherent contradictions for a group of law abiding realists - that legitimacy trumps the law.

Yes this is the well worn tale of workers triumphing over the evils of capitalism - BUT these workers take over the factory to run it making a profit, in a ruthless marketplace, and fight eviction and rubber bullets from the authorities to make it happen.

More than anything this piece is about human dignity in the face of socalled inevtiability. Global theme with portents for North American manufacturing workers (? - wanna bet we'll be hearing about this real soon) and facilties. Tight, well produced storytelling. My only complaint: I could stand to hear more.

Comment for "Paul Winter Consort and the Sounds of Nature" (deleted)

User image

Review of Paul Winter Consort and the Sounds of Nature (deleted)

Intriqued by the songs of whales and wolves. Paul Winter is. A short informational piece on Winter and the influence that wild creatures can have, and do have, on the music he and his bandmates play. With brief yet haunting musical excerpts - one recorded in the Grand Canyon.

Comment for "Hard to Say"

User image

Review of Hard to Say

A lovely piece. An elderly man tells his story, of finding love and marriage again late in life. His wife is then hit with Alzheimer's and institutionalized. Personally I really enjoy listening to this sort of intimate, quiet and revealing tale. By the end I certainly want to hear more. A short piece like this and the follow ups or furtherances are the sort of thing I would like to hear over a period of weeks or months even.